06 Oct 2025 11:34:16
We need to try and go for someone like Marco Rose, or Roger Schmidt.
I don't want Gerrard, he's not good enough. Another project manager is a gamble - as is every appointment - but we need someone with character, experience and with something about them.
Whoever it is, we need a new back 4 to make us solid and hard to beat.
06 Oct 2025 11:47:44
Just playing devils advocate but does gerrad not have character, something about him and already has experience winning a league here whilst going nearly 60 league games without losing?
i've said a few times i'd rather somebody new but I wouldn't be upset if gerrard was appointed.
06 Oct 2025 11:47:55
We need to go and get Derek McInnes Pauly. We don't need another foreign experiment thinking that they can implement their own style on the SPL. We need someone who knows this league inside out, who knows the player and mentality required. McInnes has been the answer for years along with players like Lewis Ferguson, yet we opt for people like Clement and Diomande. let's get back to our roots, standards and traditions.
06 Oct 2025 12:01:21
Totally agree PaulyDon I would add Muscat to those names, our problem being as you say is the back four, Tav and Soutar are out of contract at the end of this season and the other three are loans so they will be going back which leaves us only Stirling (if he ever gets fit), a good team is usually built from the back and who ever comes in has that problem along with other problem of getting the players to play well as they seem to be low on confidence at the moment, which I feel Martin sucked all that out of them, I do feel we have a good bunch of players they just need pointed in the right direction.
06 Oct 2025 12:05:38
Has everyone just ignored all the Rangers men and Scottish players/ British players we've bought over the last 10 years and that have failed. We need winners we need passion the Germans certainly know how to do both and detest loosing. I'd like schidmit but wouldn't be against rose. Our probably most progressive window of the last 10 years was a European / African based window with koppen last year and we just threw it out the window and went back down the English route that's failed time and time again I actually remember arguing on here in the summer about how this was going to cost us and it looks like I'm right so far …. it could change but I very much doubt it.
06 Oct 2025 12:10:10
Took years for Gerrard to get up and running, he won't get that time again and he's done nothing at all since. He done a job and I'll always be grateful but it's time to move on.
Mitchel, there's no way McInnes is leaving Hearts, and while I think he could improve us, we need to try and be a bit more ambitious.
Jorg, If we couldn't get either of those two I'd definitely give Muscat a go and aye I think a good manager will get a lot more from this squad.
06 Oct 2025 12:13:32
Agree Mitchel, but be prepared for the connotations a post like this brings, good to see you at the last klan meeting by the way.
06 Oct 2025 12:56:44
Paulydon, the defence has been a scare since 55, but no-one at the club seems to see it! When did we last concede a 'good' goal, it's just pathetic defending. Hope that's the first thing that gets sorted .
06 Oct 2025 14:55:32
Pauly I'm not advocating for Gerrard in this post but that's simply not true, he took over a real rubbish show and very quickly managed to get us through some tricky qualifying rounds to get into Europe, unlike managers recently we saw improvement with him and at this point that's what the fans need.