19 Oct 2025 14:53:08
Muscat is not ideal as we have to wait till November to get him although I would be happy with him as the new manager we really need someone in ASAP, honestly I would make Derek McInnes a ridiculous offer to drop hearts and come now. Let's face it would probably save money given the amount of compensation we would have to pay to get Muscat.
19 Oct 2025 15:06:17
Don't you think Hearts would demand compensation for McInnes?
19 Oct 2025 15:08:27
I think our best bet of Celtic not winning the league is leaving McInnes at hearts.
I would be succession planning for McInnes after Muscat a few years from now hopefully.
19 Oct 2025 15:11:19
Allegedly Hearts would want £500k for McInnes and Shanghai are report after 5 times that for Muscat. And Muscat will be on a much bigger wage. Makes no sense but trying to convince DM to come with the shambles of a hierarchy we have would be the biggest hurdle.
As long as the Thelwel crew are at the helm we ain't getting a decent, reputable manager and that why we ended up with RM in the first place!
19 Oct 2025 15:23:28
Derek Mcinnes is doing a very good job at hearts but i definitely prefer Kevin Muscat to be our next manager/ head coach, as opposed to derek mcinnes ? Muscat the better manager for me, no doubt ???.
19 Oct 2025 15:30:39
Muscat is by far a better manager than McInnes. Stop thinking short term.
19 Oct 2025 15:34:51
There seems to some type off Scottish snobery at ibrox for some reason. Only a select very few Scottish players or managers get a mention nowadays. We always had a 6-7 players in our teams far back as long as I can remember mostly off international pedigree. Now we constantly over look to give primadonnas big expensive contracts.
19 Oct 2025 15:36:46
I genuinely don't care who wins the league.
19 Oct 2025 15:41:30
Whats your reasoning of wanting Muscat over McIness? Interested to know why you think he's better.
19 Oct 2025 15:51:27
Well said.
19 Oct 2025 15:58:47
The compo to Shanghai's is not 5 times what hearts would want for mcinnes its 3 times the amount ie. shanghai want £1.5million compo for Muscat and hearts 500k for mcinnes ?.
19 Oct 2025 16:03:08
The scottish players we've have jibjo, soutter, Cameron who are supposedly up there with the best of scottish players in their position ain't good enough. So this so called snobbery ain't a thing, mckinnes is doing well at hearts but let's see how he does at seasons end. Just remember the same ones shouting about snobbery were the same ones saying we should get thelin of Aberdeen and Martindale.
19 Oct 2025 16:13:13
Muscat deal is now in jeopardy!
19 Oct 2025 16:14:43
No manager is coming to work under thelwell, the club are a joke.