07 Oct 2025 10:02:23
I don't get the hype over Muscat ~ his only experience has been in Australia and China, so no European management. Feels like another Ange Postecoglou to me. Also, he was only with us for one season.
07 Oct 2025 10:39:00
Another ange who dominated and won every title going at our rivals? ?.
07 Oct 2025 10:46:18
If you bothered your arse to research you'll have seen he has managed in Europe, albeit a very poor 6 months in Belgium. And if he's another Ange then that would be ideal; someone who comes in and obliterates the league for 2 years and leaves.
07 Oct 2025 10:48:16
How many trophies did the fat gravey guzzler win? And you don't want this?
07 Oct 2025 10:51:59
Mols, So he has only managed in Europe for six months and it was a poor six months.
07 Oct 2025 11:03:27
To be fair to him, he managed a small town team who I don't think have ever won anything of note so I wouldn't judge him too harshly for that.
07 Oct 2025 11:05:32
The OP stated no European management which isn't true Mols just stating he had. It was poor, but we aren't getting a manager who has excelled everywhere a lot of people want SG he has failed in his last 3 jobs now.
07 Oct 2025 11:34:52
Ah the usual pleasant posters ? Not Ange by tactics but experience. The same Ange who almost relegated Spurs and will soon be sacked by Forest? We need a manager with strong European experience and a winning track record in a top league. Muscat is a risk and relatively unknown manager. Do we want that again?
07 Oct 2025 11:38:24
Massive difference with Gerrard as he knows what this league is all about, winning it undefeated.
07 Oct 2025 11:40:33
Clement was experienced european manager.
07 Oct 2025 10:49:35
BenLora, think that's the exact reason. Ange absolutely roasted Rangers brought in all the correct players. And people see Muscat as very similar to Ange.
07 Oct 2025 11:28:36
Ben he's managed in Japan too and won trophies wherever he's been bar Belgium.
07 Oct 2025 11:52:49
We need a manager that's won trophies.
Exhibit A. Kevin Muscat who has won multiple trophies in 3 different countries.
Nah, not him.
Let's go for Derek Mcinnes instead who has won how many trophies?
07 Oct 2025 12:05:43
Just my opinion, which everyone is entitled to. Our club has been in a state for too many years, players, owners and management. When Ange managed Celtic we were still in turmoil and yet another transition. I would rather we appointed a manager, who not only knows our league but also the demands of the job. Managing in China, Japan and Australia just doesn't do it for me ~ as you never see successful managers going over there. Whoever comes in won't get time.
07 Oct 2025 12:09:18
Mcinnes hasn't won any trophies because of the clubs he has managed. Our league only has two teams, remember. And given a chance at Rangers, I believe he would win trophies. When was the last time any team won the league apart from Rangers or Celtic?
07 Oct 2025 12:16:21
Scott, Clement won the league back to back with two different teams in Belgium, out after around one year, Gerrard knows what this league is all about winning it undefeated.
Any manager will need to get patiences from the support, will it happen is a different story, we can't keep this revolving door happening with little or no success.
07 Oct 2025 12:19:04
He has won trophies in 3 different countries so it shows can adapt to the league.
Every manager is a risk, but one that's won plenty or trophies is a good start!
07 Oct 2025 12:40:57
Benlora Aberdeen appointed a new manager last summer and won the scottish cup killie beat Celtic in a final while mcinnes was a manager in Scotland and Callum Davidson won a double at St Johnstone so can't use the teams mcinnes has been at as an excuse for not winning an trophies.
07 Oct 2025 16:36:14
Wishy
Only reason he won here because gers were ####. He's been accosted by Spurs because they were #### and made them worse and in process doing same to Forest. In year he'll be Assistant at Crewe Alexandria. A pretender with nothing but pretence.
07 Oct 2025 16:57:45
He also lost 8 trophies out of 9 ?.