05 Nov 2025 19:35:15
EHL u say your far happier than most with our squad having worked with both us and hearts. I'd be interested in your opinion (and others) on a combined X1. How many of our players would get in their team just now? None of our defence or attackers for a start.
05 Nov 2025 22:13:23
Butland
Tav, Halkett, Findlay, Milne
Devlin, Raskin
Gassama, Shankland, Kyziridis
Braga
Most won't agree, but having watched all of our games this season and a good few of Hearts, that's how I'd split it based on form/quality.
And in that I'm being kind on Gassama and Raskin. Could easily have slipped Kingsley in at LB and moved Milne to the right, with Baningame ahead of Nico on form, which really should be the only indicator.
05 Nov 2025 22:45:45
Kaiser, it's difficult as the Hearts squad are confident and in form and we're neither.
However, just looking at the ability and levels of the players, the my strongest eleven from the combined squad wouldn't have any Hearts players in it.
I've said before, the only player I'd consider starting is Baningame.
05 Nov 2025 22:48:45
Butland, Raskin and Gassama are only ones that'd push to get in GDog I'd agree. Maybe Cornelius.
06 Nov 2025 00:55:05
Cant really argue with that lol.
06 Nov 2025 07:12:12
EHL wow. To say none from a team blowing the league away would get in our team who've struggled to to get top 6 so far and been battered in Europe is staggering but appreciate your opinion.
06 Nov 2025 10:06:46
Not really surprised by what EHL says, i believe Hearts are punching above their weight at the moment and flying with confidence. On paper at least our team should be stronger in about every department than theirs. Hopefully we start seeing that coming through, whether it will be too late or not who knows.
Anyway its good to see the likes of hearts giving us all a different line of discussion than the usual scripts.