18 Feb 2026 07:36:46
Read in the papers this morning apparently we are weighing up a summer mover for Dundee CB Luke Graham. Hope this one's a goer. Really like this young lad. Plus wouldn't cost an arm and a leg 👌🏽
18 Feb 2026 08:15:36
Hopefully I'm wrong, as I'd like us to sign the best Scottish talent, but I'm not convinced this would be a good move.
18 Feb 2026 08:54:40
An ideal replacement for Nsiala.
18 Feb 2026 09:46:18
What happened to Jack Milne being the pick of the young Scottish CBs?
I only watch these teams when they play against us, so I don't have much insight into who's who.
18 Feb 2026 09:58:02
They knocked back a 900k+ offer from an English team. So, I was told. He's got over 100 appearances, and his stats are supposedly good. Only 2 months older than Chermissy, and guess what? Luke Graham has 7 goals as well. The same as our star boy. I don't see any mention of fans saying that Luke is still learning his trade.
;) I think it may be a good buy. I don't know what's going on with John and his contract situation, but I'm not too bothered if he stays or leaves. Luke would sign on less wages, is younger, faster, has more sell on value, and has a better injury record. Seems like a good target.
18 Feb 2026 10:15:04
Whine, Souttar wants more than we r offering.
Aberdeen value Milne in excess of 5 million.
18 Feb 2026 10:15:47
John, if the lad from Dundee signed, would he be Nsiala's replacement, as in cb number 5? Do you rate the lad Milne from Aberdeen better?
18 Feb 2026 10:27:05
He may well be a good back-up, but I'd like, when we sign some of the young Scottish talents in the league, for us to loan them out for a season, or even a second one, at a level like League One down south, as they might not be ready for the Championship.
18 Feb 2026 10:41:35
Whine, grow up with the crap chermissy patter.
I agree, re Souttar. He can be good on his day, but between those he can be distinctively average, prone to a blunder and an injury.
Bringing in young, hungry Scottish players keeps the squad fresh.
18 Feb 2026 10:48:51
J-zer, Jack Milne is right-footed, Luke Graham is left-footed.
18 Feb 2026 11:04:32
Souttar shouldn't even get a new contract. A thank you and a goodbye should be all he gets.
18 Feb 2026 11:05:27
No point in buying the guy if he isn't going to be in the matchday squad. We've got a long history of not having enough faith in youth, so taking on a guy who is holding his own to shove him out on loan would be a waste of time. He'd end up a future starter for a rival SPL side.
18 Feb 2026 11:07:39
Athole, that only says more about him/her.
18 Feb 2026 11:27:55
Souttar doesn't want more money. Know the family personally.
18 Feb 2026 11:31:56
What a pile of pish. We need to be offering at least a year's extension to Souttar, who has been by far our best defender this season. Just because he's the designated blame hound for some people, the truth is plain to see.
18 Feb 2026 11:56:50
And it is 7 goals in 120+ appearances, with 6 at least against lower league teams (League 1 mainly). Only 1 goal in the SPL this season (YC has 7).
At least, if you are trying to make a point, be accurate.
🙈
Similarity granted, he is 2 months older, and this is his first time at SPL level. So he might still need some development if we do sign him; sort of more like Fernandes.
18 Feb 2026 12:09:04
From what I've seen of them, I'd rather have Luke Graham than Jack Milne. Aberdeen's valuation of Milne is way too high, both have had similar playing careers and similar paths to first-team football, with both having a couple of caps for Scotland's under-21s. If Graham is 4mil cheaper, then it'd be a no-brainer. I'm hearing we're also interested in Lecce CM Lasanna Coulibaly (4mil euro).
18 Feb 2026 12:28:42
Luke Graham has 2 goals this season, 6 in his whole career up to now, which includes goals in the lower leagues, and that's ok, he is a defender after all. Comparing him with Chermiti, though, is just utter nonsense.
18 Feb 2026 12:45:50
Just because Souttar was our best defender for a period this season, that does not give any real credit when you look at the other defenders.
Fernandez has overtaken him on that front anyway, which, considering Fernandez wasn't given a chance under Rm, says a lot.
And don't even mention Djiga. 😂
Souttar has made big tackles/blocks on occasion, fair play, but he's far from a great and reliable CB if we want to push on.
Plus he's also out injured a lot, or at least so it seems.
Souttar is fine as a backup but we need better.
18 Feb 2026 13:38:49
Bunsster, I don't think Nsiala plays for us again.
imo, Milne shows a bit more than Graham at present, but I don't think either is a starter yet, so five million plus for a bench player is a bit steep.
I think both will be full internationals soon. Another ch I like in Scotland is Connor Allan.
18 Feb 2026 13:42:06
Do the bouncy. Why did he not sign the deal on offer?
18 Feb 2026 14:37:08
John, I imagine that he wants to get the best deal for him and his family. Coming up to 30, this would be the last chance for a decent deal. Also, why would he take the first or even second offer when there is still a while to go to the end of the season. He is a current Scottish international, and would probably get a better deal down south in the Championship, seeing as Hanley was reportedly getting 30k at Norwich.
The fact that he has refused is not a bad thing; just a player doing what is best for him. No issues with that.
18 Feb 2026 15:03:25
Would anybody sign a contract when they know he'll get better elsewhere? His current wage would be doubled in the Championship.
18 Feb 2026 15:14:59
John, you ask a question either thinking I know the answer to that, or trying to be smart. Both are things you regularly call people out for on here. There is no need for that kind of answer. If you know, or think you know, the answer to your seemingly rhetorical question, then share it with the rest of us. This posturing has no place here.
18 Feb 2026 18:37:38
To be fair to Souttar, we can't keep saying he's first choice, then pay him less than what he could earn elsewhere, or pay guys coming into the club who are not doing as well as him more, and still expect him to sign.
And, don't get me wrong, I'm not a huge Souttar fan, but I will never fault the guy's desire to win or his effort.
18 Feb 2026 18:43:55
Certainly not trying to be smart. Knowing the family, u may know the answer.
Go and take a.
18 Feb 2026 20:00:48
A look see if u can update anything.
18 Feb 2026 20:14:05
I'll drive Souttar down to any club in the Championship free of charge. 👍 If he can get double, then see you later. He is not committed. 👍
18 Feb 2026 20:18:09
Hanley that plays for Hibs, Angus. 🤔
18 Feb 2026 20:30:34
30 k, really, think I'd go too. 😉