28 Apr 2025 16:11:13
If true Marco Rose is potentially going to be the new Manager of RFC
My question is
Is he going to be any better then:
Pc who won leagues
GVB also won a league.
Beale.
Barry .
What sets Rose aside from above or are we in danger of going down the same old road.
Me personally would prefer an experienced Scottish manager, who i don't know or Stevie G .
28 Apr 2025 16:41:17
What sets gerrard apart from clement or gvb who also won the same amount as sg?
28 Apr 2025 16:48:54
Like every suggestion we will see bad and good points to them all. But we will get behind whoever it may be. And let's hope for once we are nicely surprised at the job they do. i'm more interested to see what players come in tbh. We need a huge clear out.
28 Apr 2025 17:12:51
I honestly don't think whether the decision on our new manager has been taken or not, there will be any announcement from the club until after the final game against hibs at ER at the earliest ?.
28 Apr 2025 18:41:56
That would not be my question.
Mine would be is this new manager going to be given some time to build something at our club or will there be calls to sack him 4 games into a season like the last couple of managers.
As for the Scottish manager idea, good in theory if you look at our history as a winning club. But on the practical side there are very few, if any at all, good Scottish managers.
28 Apr 2025 19:20:15
There is zero Scottish managwr experienced or not who should get the job.
28 Apr 2025 19:45:52
The only decent scottish manager is david moyes and i'm not sure he would be the answer at all. great scottish managers seem to be a thing of the past when fergie retired so did the scottish managers.
28 Apr 2025 20:27:16
If someone could come up with a manager guaranteed to bring success we'll have him, unlikely so let's just get behind whoever is given the honour and not prejudge.
28 Apr 2025 20:33:28
Paul I'm not all for Gerrard coming back mate, wouldn't be annoyed though. To answer your question, what sets them apart. 1.The team Gerrard inherited was absolutely night and day to the teams gio and clement inherited. Gerrard had to build a team from scratch, literally!
2. A title
3. An unbeaten season (really hard thing to achieve)
4. The beating of Celtic
5. His name could attract players, brought more focus on our club.
28 Apr 2025 20:36:25
Tommy I agree what any manager needs is time and we never give them that; average for each of last 6 managers is 20 months and that is because of Gerrard and Warburton's slightly longer tenure.
what makes anyone think Scottish manager would be successful either if we could even think of one (Moyes won't come) .
perhaps the discussions are still ongoing as they are struggling to make a manager believe we won't cut them loose as soon as the fans turn.
28 Apr 2025 20:55:04
Good points Boy blue and i wouldn't be totally against steven gerrard, if he was appointed our manager again ? Not my first choice, but certainly in my top 4???.
28 Apr 2025 20:55:38
Bb4 you forgot to mention the fact SG left players not good enough on high wages.
Also it's been proven that the league title was a one off.
He also fecked up a treble that was there on a plate for him.
28 Apr 2025 21:33:45
If steven gerrard had stayed storm imo it wouldn't have been a one of title win because imo he would have retained the title and that's my honest opinion ?.
28 Apr 2025 21:37:42
Storm, i know we should have won other cups under gerrard but as the late, great walter smith always said a lot of clubs can win one of cup competitions but what keeps you in the Rangers job is winning the league title year on year, that's the main one, although of course everything Rangers play in the aim without a doubt is to win it and remember how highly walter smith rated and liked gerrard and that's a fact ?.
28 Apr 2025 21:44:49
Why has it been proven the league was once off storm? wins it back to back if he stayed in my opinion, you must be casting your opinion as proven fgs.
28 Apr 2025 21:52:42
Storm, u say he left players not good enough?
Thales players were 7 ahead of Celtic, just won an undefeated league title and went on to the Europa league final. They seemed good enough at that time did they not?
Short memory again pal.
And he doesn't offer the wages that's n not his job.
See Wilson for that storm.
28 Apr 2025 21:53:42
No a didn't storm. The question was what sets them apart, meaning what did gerrard do better than the others. Can't believe am having to explain that, you really should read the post before reaching for your keyboard stormy boy ?
You really have a problem with gerrard don't you? Every post about him, your there to put him down. Did something happen between you and stevie gerrard, that we're not privy to? Spill the beans, what happened!
28 Apr 2025 22:08:15
Coops you are allowed that opinion as Mystar thinks the same but I don't and the proof is in the pudding with 1 trophy out of 9.
Not many folk now in football rate him highly as a manager coops I don't get your point about having to bring in the late great Walter smith into the debate. You do this all the time.
Would he have rated him highly on the way he left? Not a chance.
28 Apr 2025 22:40:08
More proof being in the pudding was Rangers being 5/6 points in front when he left and Celtic couldn't beat his Rangers side, Storm.
28 Apr 2025 22:41:48
Boy blue maybe that's how storm has a wee grievance against me, maybe if I changed my name he'll get off ma back, mate ?.
28 Apr 2025 22:51:38
Scottish manager? Don't make me laugh.
29 Apr 2025 00:23:38
??? Stevie.
29 Apr 2025 04:36:11
True stevieg ??.
29 Apr 2025 06:28:44
The proof is he left in the middle of the night bb4 so it's irrelevant how many points clear he was. He won 1 in 9 that is the fact. No ifs no buts. It seems you don't like facts ?. Me posting about SG is a bit like you posting about me mate ?. I am entitled to my opinion and I'll post it the same as you are all.
29 Apr 2025 11:34:00
Fact is he stopped 10 in a row storm. Won 55. That's success. Fact.
His team went onto the Europa final. I'd say that's proof he left a good squad of players.
His undefeated season, record goals against in Britain. Performances and results against far superior and richer teams in Europe, and Celtic.
The mess of the club when he came in to the position he left us in.
That is all facts and shows he was a success.
29 Apr 2025 13:22:12
Maybe it would be easier on you if he left in the middle of the day ?
I've not once debated he didn't win one in 9.
I've not once debated about how many points he was clear either ?.