13 Oct 2026 09:16:41
Lads a wee question for anyone who's interested, who was the better defensive mf , ngolo kante or Claude makalele?
Ed if u want to do a wee poll for it too that would be great mate π thanks.
{Ed033's Note -
MF poll
13 Oct 2026 09:38:51
Only one of them has the position they play named after them, Makelele every time.
Only one of them has the position they play named after them, Makelele every time.
13 Oct 2026 10:14:42
Remember back in the day reading a story about Makelele paying Β£80,000 to change the leather in his Mercedes put me right off him.
Remember back in the day reading a story about Makelele paying Β£80,000 to change the leather in his Mercedes put me right off him.
13 Oct 2026 10:06:56
Makelele reinvented the holding midfield role.
I would say only Busquets and Pirlo have come close in my opinion.
Makelele reinvented the holding midfield role.
I would say only Busquets and Pirlo have come close in my opinion.
13 Oct 2026 12:15:05
Kante not in same league as makelele or busquets.
Kante not in same league as makelele or busquets.
13 Oct 2026 13:12:07
Stevie that's a hard one mate as Kante was also superb in the holding role. Who won the most trophies that's the only way I can decide. Think it might be makelele that just edges it.
Stevie that's a hard one mate as Kante was also superb in the holding role. Who won the most trophies that's the only way I can decide. Think it might be makelele that just edges it.
13 Oct 2026 13:22:47
Kante not being in the same league, ATTI? Kante was a top player.
Kante not being in the same league, ATTI? Kante was a top player.
13 Oct 2026 13:28:18
I like busquets
Toffipops are my favourite.
I like busquets
Toffipops are my favourite.
13 Oct 2026 13:58:56
I personally rate makelele better than kante but kante was also a quality holding midfielder π.
I personally rate makelele better than kante but kante was also a quality holding midfielder π.
13 Oct 2026 13:59:42
So I've just googled it makalele won 15 and kante won 11 but kante has the World Cup and makalele doesn't. That's a hard one to decide who's best. My pick would be kante as he has World Cup also I really liked him.
So I've just googled it makalele won 15 and kante won 11 but kante has the World Cup and makalele doesn't. That's a hard one to decide who's best. My pick would be kante as he has World Cup also I really liked him.
13 Oct 2026 14:02:25
Cheers lads, I would also say makalele but listen kante absolutely without a shadow of doubt is in that class of players.
I'd say busquests may be the best of them but he is different Infact all 3 are slightly different aren't they.
Then we've got Rodri now, is he better than busquets?
Cheers lads, I would also say makalele but listen kante absolutely without a shadow of doubt is in that class of players.
I'd say busquests may be the best of them but he is different Infact all 3 are slightly different aren't they.
Then we've got Rodri now, is he better than busquets?
13 Oct 2026 14:42:18
Wallace and more caps for France, not much in it with both players.
Wallace and more caps for France, not much in it with both players.
13 Oct 2026 14:51:31
Not much in it at all mate think it just comes down to preference. Both outstanding footballers. Kantes story is unbelievable from nowhere to world champion pretty amazing.
Not much in it at all mate think it just comes down to preference. Both outstanding footballers. Kantes story is unbelievable from nowhere to world champion pretty amazing.
13 Oct 2026 19:23:53
I've never played the makalele i always played guitarπ.
I've never played the makalele i always played guitarπ.
13 Oct 2026 19:30:03
I would say it is difficult to be better than Busquets although I would have preferred Pirlo in my team. The way he anchored that Milan team was amazing.
I would say it is difficult to be better than Busquets although I would have preferred Pirlo in my team. The way he anchored that Milan team was amazing.
13 Oct 2026 20:11:13
Laudrup that's both of our good jokes died on their ars*s on this thread π€£π€£.
Laudrup that's both of our good jokes died on their ars*s on this thread π€£π€£.
13 Oct 2026 20:35:43
Nato I feel they're both different players to the point u could play them both in a 2 with a 10 ahead and that would be some mf.
Pirlo was special too.
The best teams all have a mf eith great balance.
That Milan had pirlo technical ability and vision and passion etc , ball retention and telling everyone what to do and where to be.
Gattusso was the legs and the aggression and seedorf was a bit of both.
All great winning teams need balance.
Nato I feel they're both different players to the point u could play them both in a 2 with a 10 ahead and that would be some mf.
Pirlo was special too.
The best teams all have a mf eith great balance.
That Milan had pirlo technical ability and vision and passion etc , ball retention and telling everyone what to do and where to be.
Gattusso was the legs and the aggression and seedorf was a bit of both.
All great winning teams need balance.
{Ed001's Note - Pirlo met me this week, I could tell he was very excited....}
13 Oct 2026 21:02:55
I'm meaning u could play pirlo and busquets as a 2 btw *.
I'm meaning u could play pirlo and busquets as a 2 btw *.
13 Oct 2026 22:05:26
Did u frighten him with the scouse accent Ed π.
Did u frighten him with the scouse accent Ed π.
{Ed001's Note - no mate, he was obviously a bit star struck though as he didn't seem to understand me. He did seem to be very nice though, especially considering his team had just been beaten.}
13 Oct 2026 23:46:43
What did u say to him mate ?
I always get rather ovwr excited when I meet heroes lol
End up blurting out a big complimentary phrase but in a very excitable way lol