30 Dec 2023 18:17:10
For all yous that are saying it was offside for the penalty he might have been offside but Var can’t intervene and say it’s offside.
Offside is irrelevant. VAR can only check for an offside if there is a consequence - ie a goal. There wasn’t.


1.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 18:47:10
We weren’t getting a penalty under any circumstances. I’m sure Willie Collum was looking for any excuse to chop off our goal.


2.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 18:52:12
Seeing that German, I see rangers have asked for a copy of the var audio. Can anyone clarify the footage released of the var check showing the lines drawn are a totally different incident from the sima free kick, handball.

Apparently rangers are going ballistic that the picture released is second half, opposite end of ground and involves Lundstrum in open play, not taking a free kick.


3.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:04:59
A penalty is a consequence.


4.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:10:03
Spoken with confidence gersman. Unfortunately, though, spoken without accuracy.


5.) 30 Dec 2023
30 dec 2023 19:16:03
naw, as soon as they check for anything, they check everything

var didn't intervene and say it was a pen either, they went with the refs initial decision, because if they hadnt they would only be stopping the game to give celtic a free kick made no sense sadly.


6.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:19:38
John, rangers have every right to ask. it’s a joke why the penalty wasn’t giving. I can take a defeat if a fair defeat and get we didn’t play good, but it’s a penalty all day long and the sfa need to explain why it wasn’t given. I also get they got lucky with no sending offs that should’ve been, but the decision not to give a penalty astounds me.


7.) 30 Dec 2023
30 dec 2023 19:35:17
interesting john.


8.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:25:49
If Sima is offside and involved in the penalty incident, then that’s a consequence. Same as a player played through on goal and brought down by the keeper. If the player was offside it would be brought back or am i missing something.


9.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:27:14
If they give a pen, they can go back and check any reason why they can’t give a pen and the offside would be the reason.


10.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:28:59
Correct Jfm people clutching at straws here because some ex ref has come out with this.


11.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 19:39:06
Penalty if not offside looking deep.


12.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 20:04:43
Yes but why not check at the time then and draw the lines for all to see why wait till right into the second half and say offside why not give the free kick for the offside if they didn’t give the penalty then surely they should’ve gave the offside how long does it to take to come to this inclusion, I’m asking why the ref didn’t go to the screen or why var didn’t say at the time it was offside have you seen the lines or just what I’ve saw the skys lines so long after the incident. Please explain anyone who knows as I can guarantee yous all thought a penalty till sky showed your the rubbish retake so long after it.


13.) 30 Dec 2023
30 Dec 2023 21:18:34
Why is nobody picking up on the fact if they are saying no penalty and it was bye kick and not a free kick at edge of 18 for offside.

Should it not have been a corner as Johnson was last contact to knock the ball over line

1 if no offside then pen

2. If no pen then corner (Johnson last contact )

But they give bye kick either way they try to justify it it’s wrong wether it was a penalty or offside then why was it a bye kick when they know Johnson hand balled it out says it all for me.

Asking for audio is stupid what’s stopping them recording new audio for the incident.