22 May 2021 16:51:11
Today is the reason why manager of the year awards shouldn’t be handed out till end of the season and I may get abuse for this but I don’t care as it’s my opinion St Johnstone winning the cup double in Scotland is bigger than us winning the league thoughts?


1.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 17:29:23
Is some achievement kj but winning title 55 from where wee came and them going for ten beats st johnstones great cup double.


2.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 17:42:22
As a gers fan 55 was bigger. as a neutral Davidson gets the manager of the year award. there 2nd and 3rd major trophy in there history both in the same season. exceptional.


3.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:18:28
I back my own team and manager and i'm absolutely over the moon that steven gerrard is manager of the year 👌🇬🇧 However i won't take away,
what is a terrific achievement by callum davidson and st. johnstone, in winning the cup double 👍.


4.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:36:55
Also unbeaten in the league.


5.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:45:41
My thoughts kJ . nonsense.


6.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:47:33
Agree sir Walter from catching up and overtaking not just tht but breaking 100pnts new british clean sheet record, invincible in the league and last 16 of europe is outstanding compared to when Gerrard took over. No one in football foreseen this. As no one would foresee livi doing a double even a single. However knockout competitions are not quite the same and favourable draws can help not u win. In the league u face all the opposition multiple times, and we still never lost. And european football u are facing the best teams in europe and we still lasted comfortably past christmas, and thts with coming through tough qualifiers just to get in the tournament. Gerrard has worked miracles. Fairplay to st Johnston manager he is easily second best manager of year👌👌👌 just pipping Neil Francis Lennon and Lennedy finnishing 3rd and fourth 💪😂😂😂.


7.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:47:34
I said at the time KJA91 that if Davidson won both cups he should have been manager of the year.
But like you say the votes are cast early.


8.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:54:24
Disagree Kja91, the league is the most difficult competition. Not taking anything away from SJ its a fantastic achievement but there is a reason why they will never win the league. BTY wouldn't consider giving you abuse mate your entitled to you opinion. let's face it its a toss up between the 2 and my coin has Gerrards face on both, LOL. Have a great Sat evening folks. 🍾🍾🍸🍸🥂🍻🥤🍺🍺🍹🍹🍹🤪.


9.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 18:58:15
Kja. why? Gerrard won premiership manager of the year. clues in the name. Was only ever 1 winner of that. If there's a Scottish football manager of season ( not sure if is ) then davidson all day. But the orize gicen out was leage mNager of season. simple winner.


10.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 19:09:48
Sir Walter I see your point but no not in a million years when was the last time a club out with rangers or Celtic won the cup double.


11.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 19:13:20
I would have voted for Callum Davidson because its a great achievement not only for St Johnstone but its also his first season as a manager. How many managers win a cup double never mind in their first season. Well done St Johnstone credit where credits due👏👏.


12.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 19:31:12
Sir Walter, when you take the Rangers, celtic element out of it St Johnstone manager should have got it, easy.


13.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 20:20:38
In any other season it would be a no brainer Davidson would win it. However SG in my eyes has to take it this time simply because of the significance of the league win in this particular season. To win a cup you may have to win 5-6 games and if you get the luck of the draw it helps. In league cup only team they played above them in the league was hibs. I'm in no way making light of their tremendous achievement in winning both cups though and wish them all the best, davidson has proved he can do it when it matters no matter who you play. Well done.


14.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 20:27:45
Aberdeen in the 80's kja91 👍.


15.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 21:05:31
Stevie G manager of the year for me though St J Davidson unbelievable achievement - we broke so many records and what about our goals for and against as well as that points tally.


16.) 22 May 2021
22 May 2021 22:44:07
As simple as that SuperAlly1872 and that's why our manager steven gerrard is/ deserves manager of the year 👌 Graeme Souness always said it and its true ie. any team can win cups, but the best teams win the leagues as its a marathon over the season 🤔.


17.) 23 May 2021
22 May 2021 23:30:47
I agree KJA9, davidson deserves manager of the year, the double is an unbelievable achievement on their budget. 👍.


18.) 23 May 2021
23 May 2021 00:44:29
Its because its called SPFL manager of the year. nothing to do with the cups.


19.) 23 May 2021
23 May 2021 09:02:13
It’s not Paul, it’s the PFA manager of the year.

Still think SG won correctly and whilst St Johnstone deserve real credit, their win says more about Rangers and Celtic than it does them - best of the also rans in one off games.