Rangers banter 51259


Use our rumours form to send us rangers transfer rumours.

(single word yields best result)

03 Dec 2017 15:22:12
Fantastic result for the boys but we can't ignore the standard of referring once again in a SPFL game.

No danger that was a red card on Jack folks. The replay makes it look much worse but I don't believe there's anything he could have done to prevent that from happening. Below when my points as to why I feel there was no foul at all.

1. He's first to the ball, he's played a pass and upon contact with the ball there's no contact with stevie May.

2. Upon motion off swinging his leg, trying to pull out of the challenge could cause serious damage to Jack and it's also very unlikely he would have been able to prevent contact with May after the pass was complete.

I think Jack has every right to go for that ball and he's clearly won the ball first and I am under the impression he has no intention of hurting May.

So, if another red card is over turned once again for the 3rd time this year for the same player, surely the SFA have to look at this and think improvement has to be made with the referring because the mistakes being made are constant week in week out and it's affecting every side that plays.

Agree8 Disagree5

03 Dec 2017 16:00:10
I can't believe collum didn't give windass a pen, it met every criteria that he has for awarding pens ie minimal contact, theatrical fall to the ground the only thing I can think of is that it wasnt in the closing stages of the game, he did manage to send a Rangers player off for nothing right enough. The refs are crap in Scotland but inconsistently crap.

03 Dec 2017 16:25:01
I said something similar in another post regarding the card only you explained it more thoroughly. I don't think there was any intent at all on jack's part.

03 Dec 2017 19:58:13
Probably going to get shot down for this but I thought it was a red. He got to the ball first conpleted his pass then crunched into Mays ankle it wasnt necessary he could have completed the pass and stepped away from May. Jacks a silly boy imo.

04 Dec 2017 09:39:51
Was listening to radio with the sheep loving presenter and his sidekick excuse for a contributed, both adamant it was a red, watching it l do not think Jack did anything wrong, but, when they slow it down and replay they make it look like an execution. May could have been badly injured but l think he bottled the tackle and Ryan Jack was winning that ball.
The bias of radio sheep is palpable.

04 Dec 2017 10:29:10
I have to agree guys, no red Card full stop. There is no argument for it. He wins the ball fair and square and catches the opposition player as he is following through. If that's a red Card what about the simunovic tackle on kenny Miller that ended in kenny cartwheeling up in the air? The refereeing in this country is disgusting. Windass dive was disgracefull and he was rightly punished for it but, WTF was colum doing in the celtic motherwell game? Its double standards all day long.

04 Dec 2017 10:33:48
Naw guys, you can't defend a tackle like that. He meant the follow throigh. Pity because he was by far the best player on the pitch. He just needs to cut out that kind of thing. Leave that to Peanut Heid. Don't lower yourself to its level Ryan



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass